While we—and quite frankly the whole nation—are obsessed with Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift’s romance, some of his exes think Swift is in for a big surprise. Now, let’s face it: Kelce and Swift are beyond adorable, and their worldwide romance consists of PDA sessions, adorable concert moments, and more. Basically, everyone sees them as the endgame, but some of Kelce’s former flames believe Kelce’s toxic dating habits will come back.

Maya Benberry, the winner of his 2016 dating show Catching Kelce, told InTouch: “I question the genuineness of the relationship because he’s been talking to the media a lot. I feel like Travis is a narcissist.”

Along with that, she accused him of cheating on her with Kayla Nicole during their eight-month romance. She added, “Once a cheater, always a cheater.”

While many have defended Kelce, and even defended his decision to split from Benberry to be with his girlfriend of five years, Nicole, there’s still more comments that are raising eyebrows. Sources added to the outlet that Kelce may even be continuing his flirtiness.

They said, Taylor “may be in for a shock” because he allegedly downplayed his past mistakes, and continued to be flirtatious. “He’s in love with Taylor, but there’s a side to him that she doesn’t know about.”

Now, people can make mistakes in the past, and hopefully, they learn and grow from them. Many insiders claim Kelce’s romance with Swift is unlike any other they’ve both been in, so we’re hoping for the best for these lovebirds.

Travis Kelce and Taylor Swift. Michael Owens/Getty Images.
For those who don’t know, Kelce and Swift made their relationship public in Sept 2023, but they actually got together months prior and kept their romance private for quite a few months beforehand.

Before you go, click here to see all the celebrity couples with the best stories behind how they met.

Gabrielle Union, Dwyane Wade at arrivals for Step Up’s 13th Annual Inspiration Awards, The Beverly Hilton Hotel, Beverly Hills, CA May 20, 2016.